NEWS & EVENTS

Understanding FR4 and G10 Flame Retardancy (UL94 V0)

Discover the key differences between FR4 and G10 materials, their flame retardant mechanisms, and how they meet the UL94 V-0 standard. Learn which material suits your PCB needs for safety, performance, and environmental compliance.

In today’s fast-paced electronics industry, printed circuit board (PCB) safety is crucial. Whether you’re designing high-frequency devices or automotive electronics, the flame retardant properties of your materials can make a huge difference in product reliability and user safety. This guide explains the differences between FR4 and G10 materials, explores their flame retardant mechanisms, and shows how they comply with the UL94 V-0 standard.

What Are FR4 and G10?

FR4 Material

Definition: FR4 is a composite material made from fiberglass cloth and epoxy resin.
Key Feature: The “FR” stands for Flame Retardant.
How It Works:
- Brominated Flame Retardants: FR4 is typically modified with brominated compounds (e.g., TBBPA).
- Dual Mechanism:
  - Gas-Phase Action: Bromine radicals interrupt the combustion chain.
  - Condensed-Phase Action: A protective char layer forms to block oxygen and heat.
Applications: Widely used in high-frequency PCBs, automotive electronics, aerospace, and medical devices.

G10 Material

Definition: G10 is also a fiberglass-reinforced composite but is generally used for high-voltage insulation and structural components.
Key Feature: G10 does not always include special flame retardant additives.
How It Works:
- Physical Barrier: Its high glass fiber content provides a natural barrier against flames.
Applications: Ideal for industrial components like motor wedges, circuit breaker insulators, and shipboard equipment, where mechanical strength and cost-effectiveness are prioritized.

Flame Retardant Mechanisms Explained

FR4’s Dual Flame Retardancy

Gas-Phase Protection:
- Brominated additives decompose at high temperatures.
- Released bromine radicals capture reactive species (e.g., H·, HO·), quickly interrupting the burning process.
Condensed-Phase Protection:
- The epoxy resin carbonizes, forming a dense, insulating char layer.
- This char prevents oxygen from reaching the material, further reducing fire risk.

G10’s Physical Barrier Effect

Reliance on Fiberglass:
- G10 depends mainly on the inherent non-combustible properties of glass fibers.
Limitations:
- Without chemical additives, the resin can soften and even drip under high heat, making it less effective in stopping fire spread.

Understanding the UL94 V-0 Standard

What Is UL94?

Definition: UL94 is a standard developed by Underwriters Laboratories to assess the flammability of plastic materials.
Test Criteria for V-0:

The material must self-extinguish within 10 seconds after the flame is removed.
No burning droplets should be produced that could ignite other materials.

Why UL94 V-0 Matters for PCBs

Safety First: Materials meeting UL94 V-0 help prevent the rapid spread of flames, ensuring a higher level of safety in electronic devices.
Performance: Most FR4 products are designed to meet this stringent standard, while conventional G10 materials often fall short, typically achieving only V-2 or HB ratings.

Performance Comparison: FR4 vs. G10

Key Parameters

Parameter	FR4	G10
Flame Retardant Rating	Typically meets UL94 V-0	Generally reaches UL94 V-2 or HB
Flame Retardant Mechanism	Dual action: gas-phase & condensed-phase	Mainly relies on the physical barrier of fiberglass
Thermal Stability	Higher glass transition temperature (Tg > 130°C)	Lower Tg (typically below 130°C)
Mechanical Strength	Balances flame retardancy with excellent electrical properties	Superior mechanical strength and insulation

Applications in the Real World

FR4 Applications:
- High-frequency communication devices
- Automotive electronics
- Aerospace and medical devices
G10 Applications:
- Industrial components such as motor wedges and insulators
- Applications where mechanical strength and cost are more important than flame retardancy

Environmental Impact and Future Trends

Environmental Regulations

RoHS and Beyond:

Regulations like the EU’s RoHS restrict the use of halogenated flame retardants.
FR4 materials are evolving to include halogen-free alternatives to meet these stricter environmental standards.

Advancements in Material Technology

For FR4:
- Continued improvements in halogen-free flame retardant formulations.
For G10:
- Emerging modifications using nanoclay and phosphorus-based additives to boost flame retardancy.
Multifunctional Composites:
- Future composites may combine high flame retardancy, superior mechanical strength, and additional features like electromagnetic shielding.

Conclusion

In summary, both FR4 and G10 are essential materials in the electronics industry, yet they serve different roles:

FR4:
- Offers superior flame retardancy through brominated additives.
- Consistently meets the UL94 V-0 standard, making it ideal for safety-critical applications.
G10:
- Excels in mechanical strength and cost-effectiveness.
- Suitable for applications where high flame retardancy is not the primary concern, though improvements through modification are underway.

When selecting materials for PCB design, consider your project’s specific requirements, including safety, performance, and environmental standards. By understanding the strengths and limitations of both FR4 and G10, you can make an informed decision that ensures both product safety and efficiency.

Leave a message

* Thank you for visiting our website. We hope you found the information you were seeking.
* If you have any questions about our products, pricing, or would like to schedule a consultation, please contact us.